Easy but not quick Fondant potatoes aka 3 hour Potatoes
This is a recipe that was originally created by Mark Bittman who is known for simplifying recipes. And if I am honest, quite a few of his recipes make into my repertoire with some tweaking. This is no exception. It is easily in my top 3 most requested potato recipe and would be number one if it didn’t take 3-4 hours to make. Wait…come back…it’s mostly 3-4 hours of ignoring the potatoes while they slowly cook, active time in this recipe is about 20 minutes.
Ingredients:
Potatoes (Duh)
Butter (no substitutions, real butter only)
Salt
Optional: Pepper, garlic, herb of choice
Note: Before I tell you how to make this recipe, we need to have a chat about potatoes and why I don’t put in ingredient amounts. Like most of my cooking recipes this one is very flexible. You can pretty much use any potato for this. My personal preference is Yukon gold. Ideally about 3 inches in size and rather uniform. The reason for the size is that you are going to be standing them up on their ends in a deep cooking vessel. This can be one of those deep frying pans, a braiser or a Dutch oven, doesn’t matter what you use so long as it has a tight fitting lid and has enough height to let your potatoes stand on end. You need to be able to trap the steam. It is the key to the flavor of this dish. If you are using HUUUUGE Russet potatoes, you can cut them in half or thirds or whatever will work.
Method:
Peel enough potatoes to fill but not crowd your pan. The potatoes should not touch, they can be quite close however and ignore social distancing rules. Cut off the top and bottom of the potato to create a cylinder, be generous because this is the part that will be developing a delicious golden crust (and believe me, you want that crust). In a professional kitchen, these would be cut to look exactly the same but I kinda like the variety. Place the potatoes in cold water while you prepare your pan and your aromatics if using.
Place your pan over medium heat and put in 2-4 tablespoons of butter. How much depends on the size of the pan you are using. Smaller pan, use less butter. You want enough so that there is a thin layer across the whole pan. Melt the butter until it is foamy but not colored. Turn the heat to LOW (as low as your stove will go). Place your potato cylinders into the pan so that they are standing on end. Salt generously.
Add your aromatics if using.
Cover tightly with your lid. Now set your timer for 45 minutes.
When your timer goes off, flip the potatoes to the other end. Cover. Set timer for another 45 min. Repeat.
Repeat until the potatoes are very tender inside and browned on both ends. Roughly 3-4 hours depending on the size of your potato. A knife inserted into the potato should melt in like butter.
What you should end up with are lovely little cylinders that are brown and roasty at both ends. Classically, at this point you would just take the potato out and serve. I, however, prefer taking the additional step of raising the heat just a tiny bit and browning the sides of the potatoes till they are golden brown and delicious.
Sprinkle with a little bit of extra salt and serve immediately.
Gorgeous, caramelized on the outside, the insides are soft, buttery and fluffy. The secret here is the butter steam. During the long cooking time the essence of the butter has time to permeate and perfume the entire potato flesh.
Heavenly!